Acoustic comfort: carpet wins
Carpet is unbeatable for acoustic absorption. It reduces impact noise (dropped objects, footsteps) by 25 to 35 dB depending on the product, and helps absorb airborne noise in the room. In a hotel, carpet in corridors and bedrooms considerably reduces nuisance between rooms.
Vinyl (even with an underlay) cannot reach these levels. There are systems with a specific acoustic underlay that improve the impact index, but they stay below carpet.
Verdict: if acoustic comfort is a priority (hotels, open-plan offices, public bodies), carpet is superior.
Upkeep and hygiene: vinyl wins
Vinyl is maintained with a simple mop and ordinary products. In a professional kitchen, a hospital corridor or a space at high risk of liquid soiling, vinyl is essential. Impermeable, it does not hold moisture and does not encourage bacterial growth.
Carpet requires daily vacuuming and an annual professional hot-water-extraction clean. In spaces with a high food or hygiene risk, it is prohibited.
Verdict: for kitchens, changing rooms, technical rooms, spaces with liquid traffic, vinyl is mandatory.
Total cost of ownership: it is more nuanced
To buy, carpet is often cheaper than high-end vinyl. But over 10 years, the professional upkeep of carpet (annual hot-water extraction) represents a recurring cost that is not negligible.
Vinyl generally lasts longer (15-20 years vs 10-15 years for carpet in intensive use). With vinyl tiles, partial replacement is easily feasible.
Verdict: the total cost over 15 years is comparable. Carpet is cheaper to install but costs more to maintain. Vinyl amortises better over the long term.
A free, no-obligation quote with a fast reply. Over 28 years of craft near La Rochelle.
Looks and atmosphere
Carpet creates a warm, comfortable, hushed atmosphere. It remains the benchmark choice for hotel bedrooms, reception lounges and offices that want to project a premium image. The modern EGE ranges offer a very wide variety of patterns and colours.
Vinyl has made enormous aesthetic progress. Vinyl planks with a wood or stone design are now very realistic. For a restaurant, a retail space or a mixed office/showroom space, vinyl brings a contemporary, easily customised touch.
Verdict: carpet for the hushed and the traditional high end, vinyl for the contemporary and the versatile.
Frequently asked questions
A project in Charente-Maritime?
CB Sols supports you from selection to laying